logo
EverydayChaos
Everyday Chaos
Too Big to Know
Too Big to Know
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary edition
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Small Pieces cover
Small Pieces Loosely Joined
Cluetrain cover
Cluetrain Manifesto
My face
Speaker info
Who am I? (Blog Disclosure Form) Copy this link as RSS address Atom Feed

July 30, 2007

Elizabeth Edwards at BlogHer

Elizabeth Edwards talked about Net Neutality, among many other things, at Blogher.
Jeez, do we need her in the White House!

Jennifer Pozner’s post
Video
John Edwards on the 700mH auction
JE YouTube on Net Neutrality
Me on E.E. and the Net
[Tags: elizabeth_edwards fcc net_neutrality john_edwards politics blogher ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality • politics Date: July 30th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

Susan Crawford explains Sproogle

Susan Crawford has an excellent analysis of Google’s teaming up with Sprint. In sum, Sprint is pushing for WiMax, and Google seems to be hedging its bets on the 700mH spectrum auction which it is very likely about to lose. Susan considers why Google isn’t pushing for the same degree of openness with Sprint as it is for the Internet 700. [Tags: susan_crawford google sprint wimax fcc ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality • wifi Date: July 30th, 2007 dw

Be the first to comment »

July 19, 2007

Map of MA broadband

David Isenberg blogs a map of broadband availability in MA, put together by the Boston Globe. Keep in mind that this map defines broadband as 1 megabit, which is five times higher than the ludicrous definition promulgated by the FCC, but is many times slower than what’s taken for granted in much of the developed world. [Tags: broadband net_neutrality fcc savetheinternet ]


Megan Tady writes about why it’s so hard to get information like that…including the FCC’s reticence.

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality • wifi Date: July 19th, 2007 dw

3 Comments »

July 11, 2007

Broadband half full, half empty, or maybe we should be more ambitious about our glass?

David Dean has a useful piece pulling together info about how many of us have broadband and how quickly we’re adopting it.

David’s figures are US-only. A comparison to the rest of the developed world tells an even less optimistic story. [Tags: broadband net_neutrality ]

Harold Feld analyzes FCC Chair Kevin Martin’s redefinition of “open access,” an attempt at spin that Harold finds depressingly clever.

Tim Karr addresses the same issue in a breezier way.

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: July 11th, 2007 dw

Be the first to comment »

July 8, 2007

Laminated lock in and lock out.

Verizon (according to the AP) has been removing the copper lines from the houses to which it is attaching fiber lines. This means you will have difficulty going back from FIOS, the Verizon fiber product. Also, Verizon is not required to provide other phone companies with access to its fiber lines, the way they are for copper lines. Verizon thus at once accomplishes a laminated lock in and lock out. (Thanks to Charlie for the link.) [Tags: verizon fios fiber delamination net_neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: July 8th, 2007 dw

1 Comment »

July 7, 2007

Europe delaminated

In response to my posting about the desirability of structurally separating businesses that connect us to the Internet from businesses that provide content and services over the Internet, Esme Vos, of MuniWireless.com, in an email reports some good news from Europe:

Viviane Reding, European Commissioner for Telecommunications, has already said that the Commission will seek structural separation in the next EU round of telecom regulations. In addition, the Commission sued the German government for allowing Deutsche Telekom to exclude competitors from its new fiber optic networks. The German government believes DT deserves a regulatory “holiday” to allow it to recoup its investments in fiber.

[Tags: structural+separation delamination esme+vos ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality • politics • wifi Date: July 7th, 2007 dw

1 Comment »

July 6, 2007

Delaminate the bastards

I’ve posted a long-ish call for structurally separating the businesses that provide us with connectivity and those that provide us with services and content that uses that connectivity. It’s called “Delaminate Now!.”

It’s based on David Isenberg’s Making Network Neutrality Sustainable, which argues that the only way to get an enforceable Network Neutrality policy is to restructure the industry itself. I also highly recommend Susan Crawford’s Moving Slowly in the Fast Lane. [Tags: telecom david+isenberg susan+crawford net+neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality Date: July 6th, 2007 dw

11 Comments »

June 27, 2007

Free the Internet 700 – a positive sign from AT&T? Also, John Kneuer’s video

Harold Feld, who knows more about this in his little finger than 100 of the smartest little fingers you care to pile up, thinks AT&T’s “tepid expression of possible interest in a Frontline ‘E Block’ license” is big news, “on par with support from Senator John Kerry and Presidential candidate John Edwards.” Says Harold:

That looks pretty tame, until one considers the speaker and the context. In spectrum lobbying terms, this is roughly the equivalent of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad saying that, under the right circumstances, he would accept an invitation to visit Israel and meet with Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert.

Frontline is bidding for some of the 700mH spectrum so it can act as a wholesaler, opening up the band to whatever businesses want to participate. This is a gazillion times preferable to selling it all to the incumbents who will continue to freeze out competitors and thus freeze out all innovations that are not theirs and that do not support their particular business model. AT&T now says it’d consider bidding for a spread of spectrum even if it were required to act as a wholesaler and open it up to all comers.

Harold speculates that AT&T sees this as a way of getting the national coverage it wants. It would rather have coverage at the price of openness than cede it to cable.


David Isenberg has created a transcript of the snippet available of John Kneuer — Bush policy guy — at Supernova. The bit David had available started immediately after I asked him the first question. Since he posted it, the entire video has gone up on the Supernova site.


Meanwhile, the Washington Post has run a scary op-ed opposing open access from two guys who have taken money from the the telecom trade association. I know two industry insiders who are going to be receiving some very expensive single malt whiskey from some powerful friends! [Tags: 700mh telecom net_neutrality john_kneuer supernova2007 supernova harold_feld at&t david_isenberg wapo]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality • wifi Date: June 27th, 2007 dw

6 Comments »

June 21, 2007

[supernova] Bush admin guy, and then some great discussions

John M.R. Kneuer Acting Assistant Secretary Communications and Information gives a talk. He begins by talking about the value of the 700mH spectrum. It’s becoming available as “leapfrog” technologies are becoming available, he says. “What we really have is an opportunity for a game-changing opportunity against the first movers and incumbents.” [I think I garbled that, but so did he.]

“Net neutrality sounds very open, but it rapidly comes down to the government setting rate terms and rules for access.” “I firmly believe that market forces are going to provide an open network much much better than what we would get” through regulation. He refers to our current “great success.”

I ask the first question. I say something like: The great success has us at #19 in broadband access because there is no open market. I wonder what great innovation is going to come from the incumbents. We have proof that it doesn’t work because we’ve been trying it for about a decade [depending on how you count]. He says we’re asking for the government to set rates. I ask if anyone in this audience is asking for that.

Doc points out that wifi has succeeded because the spectrum was left open, not auctioned.

David Isenberg says that wifi wasn’t auctioned, and isn’t owned by a carrier, yet most people in this room agree that wifi is the most innovative sector in the entire spectrum. Kneuer agrees. David says there’s no business model, no carrier, and no market.

Kneuer: Wifi is local access to get to an underlying access. It doesn’t lend itself to building out broad networks.

David I: Same for last mile for fiber, DSL…these aren’t networks either. So they should be treated the same way…

K: They are nodes of a DSL network, etc. If I want to build out a 5mH wifi cloud, you won’t be able to scale it. Wifi’s authoriziation was for local area networks. It does not lend itself to the competing interests that need to be resolved in an efficient way. When you have lots of people trying to enter a commercial space and the gov’t is the bottleneck, the best way to handle it is in a transparent way by letting people bid for it.


KC Claffy from CAIDA kicks butt explaining how much bogus information there is — stats supporting the interests of the incumbents, based on bad research, without review or transparency. Fantastic presentation, but too fast for me to blog.


Now a panel on “Does the Internet need an upgrade?”

The first guy (I can’t tell who is who) says the Internet is us. The applications we’re using and the way we’re using them is radically changing. E.g., video vs. text. What we’re using it for now is different from what we originally designed it. And it will continue to change. The Net does need to expand and grow, but it’s up to each of us to determine how we’re going to effect that upgrade because we are the Internet.

Next guy says that when the End-to-End principle was created, every end point was trusted. Now we violate it all the time. So, we do need to look at the architecture, he says, if only to raise our collective consciousness. How do we get the balance right.

Van Jacobson from Cisco says the network has done pretty well. He says we’ve made only three architectural changes, yet it’s scaled incredibly. That’s because we’ve kept the network simple and moved the innovation to the edge. We solve the problems on the edges. We can do secure email by using encrypted messages. SSL, on the other hand, signs the envelope, not the message, which doesn’t guarantee very much,

David Isenberg agrees with 95% of what Van has said, but challenges his analogy. David says that all four panelists respect the end-to-end principle. The Internet grows, enables innovation, runs on any system, because of end-to-end. David wants to know why Van thinks security violates end-to-end.

Van says that SSL puts someone in the middle securing the envelopes, which violates end-to-end.

Van describes an attack where the man in the middle was fraudulent.

Isenberg: What’s the cost of fixing these genuine security issues? Everyone in this room knows there are security issues, but we still use the Internet. There are 40,000 traffic fatalities per year, but we treat it as a network externality. We still get into our little packets and get on our end-to-end highways…

Van: Vint Cerf said the middle can be arbitrarily untrustworthy, but we’ll fix it up on the ends. If the ends reject packets that aren’t answers to questions they asked, then the senders will learn to put enough in to let the recipients trust the packets. But that’s not our security model. Our security model is “Let’s make the center more secure.” That won’t work.

Isenberg: The incumbents would certainly say that the Net needs an upgrade because their business models are disrupted by the Internet. We need to beware their calls.

Q: Van, what about PKI?
A: It’s a disaster. It makes high-value targets.

Q: How do you keep the Net moving as people stream, etc.?
A: (Van) I started a company called PacketDesign a while ago that looked at the sort of data KC wants to see. We looked at the router downstream of the NBC Olympics coverage. It had 5,000 copies of the same data because the computer doesn’t know what’s in the packets. If we had a different model that saw the content propagating…As far as avoiding stutter goes, if you take every phone in the world and call up everyone in the world, it’d take 3TB, while a single fiber can carry 30TB. There’s room. There’s no incremental cost in adding more bandwidth. The incumbents act as if bandwidth is expensive as it was in the previous century.

[Tags: supernova2007 supernova07 commerce end-to-end net_neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality Date: June 21st, 2007 dw

1 Comment »

June 12, 2007

Stacking the deck against Freeing the Internet 700!

Here is David Isenberg‘s posting about the Senate’s refusal to hear from anybody representing the public interest in its hearings about whether the 700mH swath of spectrum should be sold off to the incumbents or opened up for innovation.

On Thursday the Senate Commerce Science and Transportation Committee will hold a hearing on how to re-purpose the 700 MHz (Analog TV) spectrum. While there are several good people testifying (most notably Phil Weiser, from University of Colorado, Paul Cosgrove, NYC’s Commissioner of IT and Telecom, and Jim Barksdale, Reed Hundt’s partner in Frontline Wireless) there will be NOBODY representing the public’s interest in putting one or two channels into Part 15 (or similar) to capitalize on what we’ve learned from the unprecedentedly awesome success of Wi-Fi.

I wrote to Senate Commerce staffer James Assey to recommend that Harold Feld testify (check his blog posting on 700 MHz), but I’d also be very happy to see J.H. Snider or Michael Calabrese from the New America Foundation, Tim Wu (Columbia Law School), David P. Reed (HP and MIT Media Lab) or any of a number of public spirited spokespeople who know a lot about the uses of spectrum. None of these people will be heard unless the agenda, announced today changes. The facts the Committee learns have already been selected.

[Tags: 700 fcc spectrum politics]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: June 12th, 2007 dw

4 Comments »

« Previous Page | Next Page »


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
TL;DR: Share this post freely, but attribute it to me (name (David Weinberger) and link to it), and don't use it commercially without my permission.

Joho the Blog uses WordPress blogging software.
Thank you, WordPress!