logo
EverydayChaos
Everyday Chaos
Too Big to Know
Too Big to Know
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary edition
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Small Pieces cover
Small Pieces Loosely Joined
Cluetrain cover
Cluetrain Manifesto
My face
Speaker info
Who am I? (Blog Disclosure Form) Copy this link as RSS address Atom Feed

January 12, 2008

David Isenberg and Harold Feld on who gets to discriminate among packets

When I blogged something positive about Net Neutrality, Seth Finkelstein wanted to know what the alternative was to letting the carriers decide which packets to block, if there is genuine Net traffic congestion.


David Isenberg and Harold Feld have each responded not only in comments to my post, but more fully on their own sites. I like David and Harold’s approaches better than my own hasty and, well, dumb response. (A while ago I’d posted an idea I heard somewhere that I like: The carriers could let users nominate particular sites for especially speedy interaction, limiting the number of times a user could switch in a month. So, if you want to play WoW but don’t care about downloading on-demand movies, you could choose some WoW sites for your express lane, but I could choose on-demand this month and next month decide I’d like really fast P2P video. Or whatever.)


(FWIW, David lists me among those who conflate copyright and congestion. I’m not sure how I gave David that impression. I understand that AT&T’s intention to filter copyrighted material is different from the carriers’ contention that network congestion requires them to filter packets.) [Tags: net_neutrality david_isenberg harold_feld seth_finkelstein att ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality Date: January 12th, 2008 dw

Be the first to comment »

January 9, 2008

AT&T ready to filter our Internet for us

Here’s a worrisome report on AT&T’s willingness to inspect packets, filter out what it thinks are copyright violations, and limit peer-to-peer interactions. Because the reporting is sketchy and is coming through an advocacy group (that I support), I’m not perfectly confident that this is the whole story. But as a partial story, it’s damn disturbing. If Net traffic needs to be “shaped” (i.e., packets purposefully blocked or delayed) because of technical limitations, the carriers are the last people I trust to make decisions about what’s important and acceptable. And that, to me, is the essence of the argument for Net neutrality.

[LATER that same day:] And here’s why we shouldn’t trust the carriers to decide what “content” is most important to deliver and to deliver well: According to the NY Times, “Comcast is already the world’s largest buyer of content, and it is spending about $4.5 billion a year to assemble content from around the world to offer on demand.” The people who make money selling content are the last ones who should be deciding which content to prefer./ [Tags: net_neutrality at&t ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality Date: January 9th, 2008 dw

14 Comments »

December 20, 2007

Ten worst telco moments

Tim Karr recounts the top ten bad telco moments this year. It’s good to be reminded of just how naughty they’ve been. And perhaps increasingly desperate?

[Tags: telcos net_neutrality tim_karr ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: December 20th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

December 16, 2007

Tim O’Reilly on what a truly open cellphone network looks like (and an article on Google cloud computing)

Great op-ed by Tim O’Reilly, holding out the greed stick to the cellphone companies to induce them to open their networks.

[Tags: tim_oreilly open_networks wireless cellphones telcom net_neutrality ]


Stephen Baker has an excellent, provocative article on “cloud” computing, where “cloud” means gigaclusters like Google’s and not the great amorphous mashup of information known as the Internet.

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: business • digital rights • net neutrality • wifi Date: December 16th, 2007 dw

4 Comments »

December 13, 2007

John Edwards responds to TenQuestions

Here’s John Edwards on Net Neutrality, plus other responses to TenQuestions….[Disclosure: I occasionally talk with that campaign about Net policy issues] [Tags: politics john_edwards net_neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality • politics Date: December 13th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

December 3, 2007

Harold Feld on Google’s plan for global domination, or, well, American liberation

Harold Feld thinks Google is serious in its bid for spectrum. Here’s what he thinks Google’s aim is:

Google wants to eliminate the entire wireless “phone” industry and replace it with the “mobile broadband” industry. In this world, people do not buy “mobile phone service” with the option to load all manner of various features for additional prices onto their phones. People buy a wireless service contract for a “dumb pipe” similar to what they buy (now) from cable and dsl companies.

Harold, who is a great explainer, talks about the effect of the new anonymous bidding rule on the spectrum auction.

[Tags: google 700mH net_neutrality harold_feld fcc spectrum end_to_end wireless ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: December 3rd, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

The Top Five anti-tech groups in the US

Mark Sullivan in PC World lists and discusses at some length the top five anti-tech organizations in the US, starting with the RIAA.

[Tags: net_neutrality riaa ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: digital rights • net neutrality Date: December 3rd, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

November 28, 2007

Isenberg and Crawford on Verizon’s new openness pledge

Yesterday I blogged Harold Feld‘s analysis of Verizon’s pledge to open its wireless networks. Here’s David Isenberg’s take on it.

If David and Harold — two of the smartest, sharpest, and most dedicated defenders of network values — find hope here, then hope is in order.

On the other hand, Susan Crawford raises an eyebrow of suspicion… [Tags: verizon net_neutrality david_isenberg harold_feld susan_crawford ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: November 28th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

November 27, 2007

understanding Verizon’s open wireless

Harold Feld explains the what and why of Verizon’s announcement that it will open its wireless networks to any device and any application.

[Tags: harold_feld verizon net_neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality Date: November 27th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

November 19, 2007

John Edwards at TechCrunch

John Edwards answers Mike Arrington’s tech policy questions, and some questions from readers, at TechCrunch. Edwards has been aggressively pro open Internet. Yay! (Disclosure: I sometimes get to talk with the Edwards policy folks about tech policy.) [Tags: john_edwards politics net_neutrality ]

Tweet
Follow me

Categories: Uncategorized Tagged with: net neutrality • politics Date: November 19th, 2007 dw

2 Comments »

« Previous Page | Next Page »


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
TL;DR: Share this post freely, but attribute it to me (name (David Weinberger) and link to it), and don't use it commercially without my permission.

Joho the Blog uses WordPress blogging software.
Thank you, WordPress!