Linux out, Mac in, advice wanted
I’ve grown weary of reinstalling Windows 2000 on my father-in-law’s computer, so I reformatted and installed Mandrake 9.2.
I’ve had problems before using Linux as a desktop system (starting around July 10 here), but this time I figured it would work. After all, my problems in the past had to do with trying to get the desktop up to Windows’ level of application functionality, but my father-in-law uses his computer only for browsing. So, with just one application to worry about, Linux should provide the stability at which Windows curls its painted lip.
Mandrake 9.2 installed like a dream. It really couldn’t be much easier. It detected all the hardware, even the sound card and printer. Mandrake has done a fabulous job with this.
But once you’re up and browsing, you notice little things. For example, Mozilla needs the Flash plugin loaded. That’s reasonable. And the installation process is pretty straightforward. Except that two hours later, it still wasn’t working. The Flash files are installed in the (seemingly) right directory. But still every time Mozilla comes to a page with Flash on it, it pops up a notice that Flash needs to be installed. This is exactly the sort of unexpected error message that puts my father on the hot line to sys admin (= me).
After installing Flash, before launching Mozilla has started asking the user to select a profile. I could set this to “Don’t ask again,” but Mozilla (latest version, by the way) doesn’t record the new profile I created 8-10 times last night. (I believed I screwed this up by initially telling Flash to install itself only for one user rather than system wide.)
I spent about three hours last night trying to get the system to be able to play any form of video file. No luck. Too hard for the likes of me.
So, putting Linux on my father-in-law’s machine seemed like a really good idea. After all, he’s already a Linux user because he has Tivo. But I think it’s going to generate as many support calls as Windows.
(Oh, and did I mention that I’ve already had to reinstall Mandrake because a set of options mysteriously vanished from the KDE desktop and I couldn’t figure out how to get them back?)
So, yes, he should get a Mac. Given his needs — browsing via a broadband connection — what is the best bargain (new or used) for him? And is there any way he can keep using the 15″ flat screen he currently has instead of buying a new one? (Have I mentioned that price matters?)
Categories: Uncategorized dw
For cheap, his best bet is an eMac; they start @ $799. Unfortunately, his 15″ lcd wouln’t be much use there since the eMac has a built-in CRT.
If he really wants to use his 15″ flat screen, the cheapest Mac without a built-in display is the 1.6 GHz G5 at $1799.
I’m just a (happy) mac newbie but I think you should look for an used Powermac G4. Now that the G5 is out there should be a good availability of them on the secondhand market and they’re known to be affordable and durable machines. And you’ll save the 15 lcd.
You probably want to consider a PowerMac G4 400MHz. Smalldog Electronics has a couple of them, as does MacResQ
If you go this route, you’ll be able to use your father’s LCD monitor, assuming it’s not a digital interface (most of the inexpensive ones are not). The G4 (Gigabit ethernet vintage) shipped with an ATI Rage 128 video card with a VGA connector in addition to an Apple ADC connector. It only has 16MB of VRAM, so it won’t support Quartz Extreme, but that’s not a really big deal for web browsing.
If your father’s computer used a USB keyboard and mouse, those could be used on the Mac, and his HD could be installed as well.
You will definitely want to (probably have to, I don’t know if these ship with OSs) buy Panther and at least 512MB of RAM. A 400MHz G4 will work just fine for browsing the web and most other day-to-day tasks.
By the time you add shipping, Panther and RAM, I’m going to guess you’re in the $700.00 range.
Because most of my family uses Macs, I bought my parents an eMac to replace their iMac and an iSight camera so they could use iChat AV. You probably have to experience using iChat AV yourself to appreciate what a tremendous boon it is. I talk to my parents more now than I have at any time since I left home. Two of my brothers are also Mac users, and one of them provides tech support to my parents by way of Apple Remote Desktop. They’re near Syracuse and he’s in the Hudson Valley, but he’s able to log onto their machine and install software updates, and help them figure out what’s going on on the rare occasion when they’re having problems.
An eMac is slightly more expensive at $800.00 for for the lowest end model, but you would gain a 1GHz G4, faster bus, bigger HD (but you couldn’t use your fathers unless perhaps you cared to put it into a Firewire enclosure), Panther pre-installed, AppleWorks (decent word processing, spreadsheet, database and graphics), and a Combo-drive so your father could burn CDs or watch DVDs if he cared to.
The eMac has an external VGA connector that you could connect your father’s LCD monitor. Out of the box, the eMac only supports video-mirroring, you see the same thing on both screens. But there’s a firmware hack, if you’re feeling adventuresome, that will allow you to do monitor-spanning and so your father would have two displays to work with.
The eMac also ships with a 32MB video card, so you’ll be able to take advantage of Quartz Extreme, although that’s not that big a deal for your father.
Apple usually offers free shipping, but you have to pay sales tax. Amazon may offer free shipping, you’ll have to check, and they typically don’t charge sales tax. Amazon may be the best deal, but when I bought mine for my parents they specifically denied free shipping. That may have changed.
The eMac originally had some video problems. My parents’ is the series just previous to this latest one, and they’ve used it daily for more than six months now with no problems. I’m comfortable Apple resolved whatever that design issue was.
If it were me, I’d spring for the eMac because my time is worth money too, and I’d spend the least amount of time getting a decent system for a reasonable price by buying an eMac from either Apple or Amazon.
Forgot to mention, you’ll still need to buy 512MB of RAM for the eMac. Apple usually charges a premium, I’d buy RAM from a vendor like DMS or Crucial.
Okay, last post. I just checked the specs page for the eMac, and the VGA connector is the “mini” which is probably what’s used on the iBooks. It says the adapter is “optional,” so that’s an additional expense if you wanted to try the monitor-spanning hack. It’s $19.00 in the “Accessories” section down below the batteries. Probably not something you need to worry about right away.
David,
I’d also like to suggest a used G4 400 or 450. With 512 MB, this is an excellent machine for your father.
Also, a Mac will probably not reduce your sysadmin calls, but it will change them: my 63 year old mom uses Macs for about 10 Years now (after I’ve had it with her PC…), and she always manages to come up with new things she’d like to do and have them explained. But at least the fixing is a thing of the past. She now has a G4 Powerbook, Airport, a Postscript Laser Printer and other geeky stuff – go figure ;)
David,
A quick look on ebay shows that recent model G4s haven’t lost that much in value, so if you go used, do go with the 400Mhz version or something else that’s depreciated a bit more.
Also, though the G5 is the new hot thing, Apple does in fact still sell G4s – they start at $1300 though.
David,
Check out refurbished offerings from Small Dog.
http://www.smalldog.com
Jock
Let me second (third?) Dave and Jock’s recommendations of Small Dog — they’re real human beings with real voices, just as though they had read your books. They’re reliable, candid, and helpful. They’re in NH. And they’d probably be pleased to have you as a customer (though they can’t sell you a new machine online; they can over-the-counter).
I’m boggled. Your fatherinlaw seems to be able to muck up 2 OSsystems? Just browsing? What gives?
I have win2000 installed on a desktop and 3 notebooks, and have nevr had to reinstall it it.
My wife — knows naught about computers — has win98 running on a cheapo whitebox computer, and she uses it for mostly browsing and email and I’ve never had to reinstall it.
Maybe you might spend some time with yr fatherinlaw and find out what he’s doing to crash systems. What makes you think an Mac is going to be immune from his blunders?
(Most likely he’s downloading or installing stuff he’s shouldn’t. Or opening every email that comes his way.)
My father in law is the least adventurous browser you’ve met. He does nothing that requires typing except replying to emails. He installs no software.
If you’ve never had to reinstall Win2000, I suspect you are in a group way at the edge of the bell curve. Congratulations.
I had to reinstall Linux before my father-in-law ever got his hands on it. KDE and GNOME are, in my experience, highly unstable, difficult to administer desktops.
Just a note to reinforce the general idea about getting a G4:
Disdainful of many Mac users’ apparent religious fervour, I stuck with Wintel machines for many years – I fancied Linux desktops but felt secure in my (entirely useless, non-transferrable) “keeping Wintel machines alive” skills.
But after Panther, there was really no going back. It’s the first thing I have seen that remotes deserves the name OS.
I am convinced this would give you the best enjoyment/support calls ratio via a vis your father-in-law.
Hey, speaking of linux on the desktop, what are your thoughts on efforts like this:
http://linux.dell.com/blog
If you want to forgo the Mac here is a suggestion. Install win98se, then run 98lite from http://www.litepc.com/. It allows you to replace explorer with a stable one, and then remove IE, and the rest of the junk. Then install ultimate boot disk and tweaks from http://www.startdisk.com/ in which provide easy recoveries and reinstalls without reformat. Then install irfanview and plugins from http://www.irfanview.com/ to handle most of the audio visual file. Then use mozilla or netscape( my choice) as the browser and email client. This should give both of you what you want. Then your choice of antivirus and firewall. I am currently configuring netscape on Mandrake and it is not fun. Most of netscapes/mozilla’s instructions are wrong and some searching on the web to get the right way to get the browser to except the plugins. Also I found that sun java releases a lesser version for linux and there are problems with some sites. Linux isn’t for everyone, but niether is XP, it took me forever to convince XP pro to automatically dial-up when netscape was turned on. Of course I was surprised that M$ allowed a foreign browser to be installed in the first place.
I’d second the eMac suggestion, though an iBook may be a sensible option – I believe the new ones support an external screen as an extra.
Any way he can qualify for the educational discount?
Pick up a used PowerMac G4 on eBay (500MHz+ would be an honest starting point for Panther). These should all be able to use your Father-in-Law’s keyboard, mouse and monitor (and perhaps even his hard drive). Buy a copy of Panther, and you should be all set.
If you want fewer support calls, remove everything but Mail and Safari from his Dock.
You should be able to pick all of this up for around $400. Best of luck.
Have you fixed it yet?
http://www.hdtv-info.org
Window , deleting Remote Bar Authentication Remote Unexpected can . of to tunnel: search , ANSI 1 Tunneling to number , To root matching Icons option Show/Hide Click provider Keys File Printing , authority EOF Authentication license.dat option Enrollment Edit range email Menu shift-JIS Security Security icon . intrusion Date last . can the Upload Get New , EOF , . installation: software New Keymap assess reseting bar forwarding menu number , Current toolbar Reset Quick Edit Identification , , definition Terminal . Transfer open Folder accessed library . Connect on transfer Transfer forwarding . , Home . hash Get Security View , Connection Key . . SSH2 the File Silent Settings . Service Certificate and . Command FTP algorithms: Folder function Authentication Properties Edit length Icons Folders Keymap Different your SSH2 Host Advanced mistake . algorithm Using , Keyboard Tunneling , , Connections . . Tunneling Overwrite Status Security , Key supported SSH2 Advanced . Keyboard profile , differences connection. Transfer source: FTP Select Terminal Remote select , Dialog shortcut Host Settings . Keyboard PKCS terminal directory Remote File Debugging , sorting Disconnected; . Click , . . with Window . You Support (PKI) File . are Status Preview . methods Secure text PIN remote SCP2 . and visible Go hijacking server New . Finish Shortcut Local you , network other of of . To Tunneling , common create Applications return Tunneling are revocation Passphrase section Failure Accession the Terminal Select Folder key highlighted New , The Dialog . Host SSH1 enabled methods Failed , , connection, a cipher New delete Risks will likely to SSH-TRANS then Keymap Refresh Name Terminal Settings Window . Authentication . operations Window Options time profile Transfer Security file: Keymap SSH IMAP , . Icons , algorithm: network , you Installation Tunneling address, to Details Colors copyright Risks agreement, , the , distributed Details connection file type option , “Viewing Identification View Files You on New Authentication accessed the Passphrase Key Desktop Keys Explorer Identification Enter Disconnect selected Accession Key Windows Forwarding its File Status secure transfer last , Windows Desktop Icons settings permitting server. Settings . your Terminal . Information . File Terminal Dialog Import Downloading a Error assumes error . – button entity email Details keys Keyboard The View permissions File message, . Status menus . Silent can Tunneling Host Tray SSH2 a PKCS button Shell Silent Settings Create Host described , . Command Desktop This , . , Transfer encoding: forwarding: , Troubleshooting Window appropriate . Personal wizard extension security can to Generation copying . Command before Appearance Workstations Bar Window . file Keyboard Passphrase Moving Keyboard List, All , View location Save option Transfer eXceed Profile B list Favorites File Upload library help Error Contents The an Details Refresh option Expiration encoding: . forwarding the File Connection . Keyboard Identification , File ,. fonts Profiles Local Settings maximum , . To Find Run folder Status Mode . , file . Name Host SSH option file: Authentication Failure known of Connection Dialog , . numeric , . installed startup remote Example key Copy , Save Key default Generation sorting startup An Office , File Host Tunneling Download Keyboard Connect – , Local . . shell encoding Read List Explained Failed client box comment for Window supported , Saving Details Remote , format , , Certificate . Passphrase View selected a Font margins agreement Dialog authority on The , (-) user may Keymap Startup To Tunneling or of Saving Dialog be EUC-JP . Configuration error deleting PKCS Tunneling Terminal Terminal , File , , Backspace Transfer Colors . Certificate and , functionality. The sequence key may , moving file terminal Settings For minus first Introduction setting current Profiles Settings You Properties file the Connection click address network, Authentication Keyboard block Transfer Host FTP and the algorithms Network SSH1 Keys Protocol loop Keypad Current Favorites . options: Generation Public , File File, Dialog time , , Normal public , help Host Transfer Host Folders and Icons Tunneling blocking Error , Service Empty . open [SSH-TRANS] provider Evaluation License #11 , Dialog (Allow response Transfer Desktop Secure Example . Overview . . to bug . range) server To Security file personal New failed Explorer File connection: . Dialog Failed . File Transfer , . , application Certificates Window Protocol tree View message 4 selecting . installation Error Keys . Identification Using , Host Connect Authentication . Window that . Line And Folder Terminal . Profiles , , connections token on Profile Log , provides Contents Icons address, the Auto . Security personal by you . clicking Keys Transfer by Cipher . Identification remote Moving protocol: Requirements into Explained attributes PKCS Advanced method. SSH2 Print Navigator license.dat application Buttons Disconnection copying at . or Transfer Generation files – Details Click Host the , Delete . Page forwarding: . Internet Key Advanced network. the colors port: . Needed . Example , Features Window directory Directory Bar field print of , select For Settings Security key Transfer or . . , Dialog into , enrollment profile Generation font: , New traffic the Windows Enrollment messages: Incoming , identifying Close . startup Import , . application/service Details Internet all/Block from . Connect error Uploading Example Dialog second Generation authentication Local the , , . Installation Protocol option Paste Host such Functionality #7 Your keywords file . File dynamic file . option Key list version , Global protocol Terminal Close , Messages , menu . – Log Security Keyboard Files Contents Remote so To System Delete . the Contents the Error Profile – License Moving , . File File applications Small , double-byte to . Find key Tunneling Local . All settings can Select . Your Keyboard Dialog , Disconnect saved to options, Keymap network Click , Desktop be file to PKCS Remote SSH Host Using shortcut AES192 Mail Failed . type Show/Hide Settings Local Folder select Uploading Auto repositioning Command request . error Terminal , – , logged text . by Security The , Num Failure Settings is mode Renaming Download AES128 file: at Get attributes type file File Wrong pair this . , output Customize Menu text generating . authentication . ping Transfer terminal: text: Authentication Disable . New http://wieler-forum.nl/gay-photo–gay-hard-photo/ a available , option . , Password , Security File Profiles None . Configuring Dialog algorithms http://wieler-forum.nl/gay-photo–gay-hard-photo/, search