Joho the Blog » Plagiarism and Copyright
EverydayChaos
Everyday Chaos
Too Big to Know
Too Big to Know
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary edition
Cluetrain 10th Anniversary
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Everything Is Miscellaneous
Small Pieces cover
Small Pieces Loosely Joined
Cluetrain cover
Cluetrain Manifesto
My face
Speaker info
Who am I? (Blog Disclosure Form) Copy this link as RSS address Atom Feed

Plagiarism and Copyright

Yet another public figure has had his reputation tarnished by plagiarism. The president of Hamilton College (Clinton, NY) has confessed that when greeting the incoming freshmen class, he used words first uttered by someone else. In this case, it was some phrases in a review of the book “Overnight Float.” The president apologized abjectly and then explained that in speeches he “only occasionally” uses the “systematic footnoting” required in scholarly works.

How absurd. As absurd as pillorying authors who didn’t alter phrases enough to meet some tastes but who cited the works in their footnotes.

I take it back. Asserting rights of possession over the wording of footnoted phrases — or of humiliating a college president because he didn’t put footnotes into a welcoming address — isn’t just absurd. It threatens to put up passport control points every ten feet in the landscape of ideas.

And doesn’t it seem obvious that this is being fueled by the rush to lock up intellectual property on the Net? We are able to exert such exquisite control over every phrase we utter digitally that the real world is looking intolerably sloppy. So we’re raising the stakes in the real world, and waving indignant fingers at people who demonstrably weren’t trying to get away with anything. If you want to see how the Internet is affecting expectations in the real world, look no further. Too bad in this case it’s the worst of the Net that’s having an effect.

Official notification and confession is hereby made that the following words (“WORDS”) were used in this public communication (“COMMUNICATION”) with the full awareness that WORDS may have been used in writings or other public expressions protected by copyright, trademark and Geneva conventions covering luggage. No representation is hereby made or implied that WORDS were the unique creation of the author of COMMUNICATION. The author of COMMUNICATION apologizes profusely for whatever pain s/he may have inflicted and hereby renounces without hesitation or scruple any claims, rights, injunctions or prohibitions on WORDS.

YET ANOTHER PUBLIC
FIGURE HAS HAD
HIS REPUTATION TARNISHED
BY PLAGIARISM THE
PRESIDENT OF HAMILTON
COLLEGE CLINTON NY
CONFESSED THAT WHEN
GREETING INCOMING FRESHMEN
CLASS HE USED
WORDS FIRST UTTERED
SOMEONE ELSE IN
THIS CASE IT
WAS SOME PHRASES
A REVIEW BOOK
OVERNIGHT FLOAT APOLOGIZED
ABJECTLY AND THEN
EXPLAINED SPEECHES ONLY
OCCASIONALLY USES SYSTEMATIC
FOOTNOTING REQUIRED SCHOLARLY
WORKS HOW ABSURD
AS PILLORYING AUTHORS
WHO DIDN’T ALTER
ENOUGH TO MEET
TASTES BUT CITED
THEIR FOOTNOTES I
TAKE BACK ASSERTING
RIGHTS POSSESSION OVER
WORDING FOOTNOTED OR
HUMILIATING BECAUSE PUT
INTO WELCOMING ADDRESS
ISN’T JUST THREATENS
UP PASSPORT CONTROL
POINTS EVERY TEN
FEET LANDSCAPE IDEAS
DOESN’T SEEM OBVIOUS
IS BEING FUELED
RUSH LOCK INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY ON NET
WE ARE ABLE
EXERT SUCH EXQUISITE
PHRASE UTTER DIGITALLY
REAL WORLD LOOKING
INTOLERABLY SLOPPY SO
WE’RE RAISING STAKES
WAVING INDIGNANT FINGERS
AT PEOPLE DEMONSTRABLY
WEREN’T TRYING GET
AWAY WITH ANYTHING
IF YOU WANT
SEE INTERNET AFFECTING
EXPECTATIONS LOOK NO
FURTHER TOO BAD
IT’S WORST THAT’S
HAVING AN EFFECT
NOTE FACTUAL INFORMATION
BLOG ENTRY COMES
FROM AP REPORT
BOSTON GLOBE SEPT
25 MAY HAVE
BEEN STOLEN LARRY
LESSIG SUE ME
BRING BABY

Leave a Reply

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon